Well I can’t write a really full on review of this mouse and keyboard combo just yet as the mouse arrived somewhat crippled. Everything works but the left button microswitch sticks somewhat and it’s not worth sending it all the way to California and back for what I paid for the pair on eBay. I was able to replace the microswitch with one from another mouse that was the exact same size, but in doing so the cable that connects the thumbwheel, back/forward buttons and search button somehow got munged and works intermittently at best.
What I can say is that I like the feel of this mouse, and having the pleasure of taking it apart, I’m impressed with the overall build quality although for the (retail) price I would have expected more metal parts. I like a heavy mouse and this one doesn’t feel any heavier than any other wireless mouse I’ve used. I have a bit larger than average hands and I must say the mouse is very well designed to comfortably fit average to above average sized hands. If it were up to me I’d like to see it another 10% larger still but it’s still a good one-size-fits-all size and larger than almost all other bluetooth mice that are usually the wee size as they’re meant for portability.
If you use your laptop alot, you’ll soon realize it’s worth sacrificing a small amount of portability for long-term comfort. Those little notebook mice give me cramps in my hand after about half an our of continual use.
Well you get what you pay for when you buy refurbished so I guess I at least got my money’s worth with the keyboard and an extra bluetooth transeiver for my studio computer. If I had it to do again I think I’d just wait for a sale at BestBuy or TigerDirect or NewEgg and call it a day. I paid less than half retail and while the mouse does work okay, I could have gotten used to that thumb wheel that doesn’t work now. I thought that was a good idea not just another button for the sake of another button. As a software developer I’ll often have ten or fifteen or more windows open concurrently and thumb scrolling through them would be a real timesaver not just a gimmick. Hats of to Logitech for that. That feature is right up there the scroll wheel in my book.
Speaking of the scroll wheel, it has a neat feature if you spin it really fast it lets go of the typical clicking action and spins freely allowing you to scroll through a large amount of text in short order. The wheel is heavy enough that if you give it a hefty spin it will go for quite a while before stopping. You can feel the solenoid inside kick back in to “click” mode when the wheel slows down enough or is stopped altogether. This takes some getting used to. I think I would prefer a blend of this technology and Microsoft’s smooth scroll wheels they have on many of their mice and lose the cog action altogether. I’ve actually gotten used to another scrolling technology that is a close second to the scroll wheel; Logitech’s own MX Air mouse I use in the home theatre. The scroll “wheel” is just a touch-sensitive strip that actually makes a clicking noise that gets faster the faster you “spin” it. The only issue I have with it is that it’s a little too sensitive and gets “spinning” very vast way too quickly, but that’s a rabbit trail for another blog.
Having had a chance to take the mouse apart I can say it is well built inside and well designed, except for the flimsy cable that connects the top half to the bottom half. If I never find the short, I may just buy a new MX5500 Revolution when they come on sale next at the local BestBuy. I really liked that thumbwheel option before it died. You do need to install the Logitech SetPoint software to use some features like the thumbwheel, the search button behind the wheel, and the forward/back buttons and installing it isn’t a hassle at all.
Pairing both with the computer posed no problems. The keyboard’s LCD display even prompts you for the passkey when pairing it to the computer. The mouse doesn’t require a passkey that might pose a problem in a room full of bluetooth mice like an airport or an internet café. The range of both is very good. I’ve left the keyboard and mouse in the basement two floors down and they still connect to my laptop if I leave them on.
The keyboard has a button that converts the numeric keypad into a calculator that uses the LCD display like a simple desktop calculator. I haven’t used all the functionality of the keyboard as I bought the set mainly for the mouse for my laptop (the other Logitech MX Revolution mouse sold by itself isn’t bluetooth which is what I wanted for my laptop). The keyboard will be perfect for the studio though as I’ve been looking for an RF type wireless keyboard for the studio I can carry around to say the drumset and run the sequencer from there. There are plenty of multimedia and dedicated buttons all over the keyboard but I don’t use most of that stuff. I wouldn’t buy this set for my primary desktop for one solitary but absolutely deal-breaking reason: the keyboard is not ergonomic. It’s a plain old square keyboard with lots of bling. I absolutely will not use a non-ergonomic keyboard for regular desktop use. If you’re not a typist, you don’t type that much or just don’t care then this may not be a big deal for you but Logitech has other sets with ergonomic keyboards and the MX Revolution mouse (albeit the 2GHz variety not bluetooth but for the desktop who cares). It would find a good home in your home theatre if you use your keyboard much in that environment. I do occasionally if I’m using a web browser or something but it’s not something I use on a regular basis so as long as the keyboard has a decent range (and this one does) you should be good to go.
I haven’t run into any of the bluetooth issues others have complained about with some Microsoft mice, which also factored into why I went with this one, although the mouse does take its sweet time connecting when you first boot up. My other wireless mice connect immediately.
So here’s the bottom line:
Pros:
- Bluetooth – no need for a transceiver on most newer laptops
- One of the best ergonomically designed mice available in my opinion
- Thumbwheel on mouse is one of those must-have options for people that use a lot of applications at the same time like software developers, game developers, graphic artists, etc.
- Keyboard has a ton of multimedia keys if you dig that kind of stuff
- LCD on the keyboard can display all kinds of stuff – only time will tell how useful it actually is
Cons:
- Keyboard is not ergonomic
- Mouse is almost bereft of metal parts inside given the price
- Refurbished pair I bought was obviously not tested very thoroughly if at all
Summary:
I would buy this set for the bluetooth MX Revolution mouse for use on a laptop but only if I had a bonafide use for the keyboard, otherwise save yourself some cash and either buy the mouse by itself (it won’t be bluetooth though) or consider a set with an ergonomic keyboard. The LCD display on the keyboard has a certain whiz-bang neato factor but how useful it is is hard to say. Don’t buy a refurbished set unless it’s from a reputable big box store you can take it back to (or Logitech themselves). Once I get the mouse working properly (or replaced) I’ll be happy to add it to my other Logitech devices I use daily around the house – the MX Air Mouse and the Harmony 1000 Universal Remote. Bottom line: I absolutely love the mouse. The keyboard is neat but not being ergonomic is a deal-breaker for desktop use.
EarnieShoes Rants and Meanderings
Recent Comments